Friday, March 16, 2012

You have a dog. I have a child. It's not the same thing.

     I was enjoying a rare moment alone this morning at the coffee shop, while my laundry was drying.  I was luxuriously sipping, staring into space, and accomplishing absolutely nothing- when my moment of bliss was interrupted by a loud slap.
     I had vaguely heard a little fussing behind me.  It went something like this;
     Muffin!
     No sweetie, you can't have a muffin.
     Muffin!
     No, honey.  We aren't getting muffins today.
     MUFFIN!
     Smack!


     Holy crap.  Did mommy actually just hit her child- in the middle of Connecticut Muffin?
     Nope.  I turned to see a smiling toddler, and a shocked mother with a rosy cheek.

The face of an angel?  Sometimes.

     Had this been a year and a half ago- before I had a child- I would have probably given mommy a look of judgement and disdain.  Today- I just looked at her, shrugged my shoulders, and thought,  Great.  Is this what I have to look forward to?  I mean, this woman was clearly a good mom.  She wasn't indulging her kid, she was attentive, she kept her shit together, and she left immediately when he acted up.
     Poor, tired, embarrassed mom walks out of the shop.  Immediately, the women behind me start talking. 
     Did you see that?  God.  You can't tell me you can't teach a child 'No.'  I have a dog, and I can teach him that.  A dog.  Aren't children smarter than dogs?  Yes, they are.  Jeez.
     I have issues holding my tongue.  It's been a problem for as long as I can remember.  Maybe I was mute in a past life.  I turn around to offer my two cents.
     Do you have kids?  The dog you tied up outside before you came in here doesn't count.  
     She answers, clearly annoyed.  No.
     Well then, maybe you should shut the fuck up.
     In solidarity with tired mom- and just in case these women are prone to violence- I pick up my stuff and leave.  So much for my relaxing morning.



      
     Honestly, I don't know what it is about parenting that makes us all think it's so easy to do.  It's not easy.  At all.  And guess what, just because you have a puppy, or once spent the weekend watching your best friend's child-or whatever- doesn't make you a pro on the subject.  Try rearing something 24 hours a day- that you can't tie up outside a restaurant, or leave home all day, alone.  I'm not saying owning a pet is easy.  It is a total pain in the ass.  It just doesn't qualify you to give parenting advice or judgement.  Ever.
     My child is 16 months old.  He doesn't listen to a damn thing I say.  I don't indulge his every whim.  He just happens to be a young, rough draft of a human being- with no on/off switch, no real social skills yet, and no volume control.
     He's a wild animal that I can't put on a leash, or muzzle.  I'll repeat, that I can't put on a leash, or muzzle.  That's the difference between him, and your dog.  And that's why- by default- my life is harder.

     So give myself and other parents a break, and stop thinking you know it all because you taught your dog how to fetch and stop chewing on your shoes.  And I'll stop cursing you under my breath every time your dog's pee ruins a perfectly beautiful, fresh snowy street- or the next time I get a huge waft of dog shit when I'm on my morning walk.

Deal?

12 comments:

  1. YES YES YESSSSS!!! And BRAVO! I have a friend, and she has two dogs... and one of the dogs got sick. She had to take it to the vet. She talked about how it was just like having a child. WHAT?! WAIT. NO. DAMNIT NO. I had a dog growing up; I now have a 7 month old. I now LOAAATTTHHHEEEEEEE, like make me wanna smack my mama, loathe when someone says having a dog is like having a kid.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I mostly just hate that some people I know with dogs think that if you can tame a dog, you can tame a child. Ha. Ha.

      Delete
  2. Oh man, I hate that. My best friend has a dog, she wouldn't compare having a dog to having a child. But she threw a birthday party for her dog, I'm sure out of boredom and she just does that so whatever, but she put some pictures of it online and my mom was comment how she's such a good mother. Really? Because she threw her dog a birthday party that makes her a good mother? Granted, I think she'd make a good mother, but this isn't a child, she's just a pet owner.

    We just got rid of our dog because he snapped at our son, but we had him for 3 years and it's nothing like having a child. I can't throw my child in a cage and leave for the day, or let it outside to potty so I don't have to clean after it, or feed him only twice a day. I wish I could do some of the things with my child that I did with my dog, but I'm sure child protective services would be called on me then.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Maria, I love your blog and always look forward to your new entries. But...I feel the urge to offer a different perspective. I take issue with your statement that non-parents are not allowed to offer advice or pass judgement. People offer (perhaps unsolicited) advice on a variety of topics all day, topics of which they are no expert! Such as opinions on medical issues, relationships, money...the list goes on and on. Lack of experience does not automatically make my advice null and void.
    Look, I have no doubt that parenting is the toughest job in the world, and our society is incredibly judgmental of mothers in particular and this has to change. But I can't help but find it offensive to be told that I am not allowed to judge (let's get real people, we all judge) or offer advice just because I have not procreated.
    -J. Larson

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should take everything I say with a grain of salt- if you haven't figured that out yet! I give everyone advice about everything. For example, I just gave you advice, about not giving advice- Ha!
      This post was, for me, more about how easy some people (including myself, before I had a child) think it is to mold a human being. It's not. I imagined that I would be one of those mothers that could to the whole "hard look" thing and have my child fall into place. I'm already seeing that I doubt this will be true. I have to take him on a plane in a few weeks- and I'm having panic attacks already.

      Delete
  4. I don't think there's anything wrong with getting parenting advice from non-parents as long as it's GOOD advice. :) I have two friends who don't have kids of their own, but they have a lot of experience with other people's kids (one is a teacher and the other is a nanny) and I'll gladly take advice from them. But when it comes to my friend who has no kids, but will occasionally babysit her neighbor's daughter, giving advice--wow, thanks but no thanks. :)

    I love this post, by the way. I think what really bugs me more than getting advice from people who don't have kids (and who have no experience with kids) are the people who have dogs and refer to them as their "four legged kids." I just find it kind of pitiful for some reason.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Totally. There are probably nannies that know a hell of a lot more than me. I'm not an expert in anything- if you haven't noticed. I have to say that I am really glad that not everyone wants children. The planet is way overpopulated as it is!

      Delete
  5. Hm, well, I think becoming a parent also involves accepting that sometimes what your child does is going to bother other people, and being at peace with that. I think the mother in this story exhibited a lot more grace than you did. When you're linked by blood to a child, they can do anything and you are in a position to see it as part of a continuum you've followed since birth. But not everyone else sees everything they do as one of life's miracles. Sometimes they wish you had more control of the situation. Is it selfish? Maybe. But let's face it, we had kids because we wanted them, not because they needed us (they weren't born yet). I respect everyone who takes on the job and I pat myself on the back for it regularly, but I only have so much sympathy for grown adults whining about how hard and challenging it is and how misunderstood they are. Anyone with eyes can see how hard and challenging it is before getting pregnant in the first place, waiting for others to cheer your choices is a losing battle, and you can certainly reach deep into your memories and remember a time when someone's child was an irritant to you, too. Embrace your decision to take on this role, love your child and don't be so defensive. Haven't you ever heard of Monday Morning Quarterbacks? They're everywhere and have something to say about everything. Eavesdropping on someone's conversation (in NYC, we politely permit others to enjoy their time at their table in "private," as if they weren't six inches away) and then insulting them is not exactly laudable behavior, either.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Fair enough. I tell people to fuck off to their face, you go on a blog and post anonymously about how ungraceful its author is. See, everybody judges everybody all the time. That's life, and I'm OK with it. And I live in NYC too, so I'm not so sure about your last statement.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh, Guerilla Mom. You don't seem to mind anonymous posters who agree with you, and they're remaining anonymous for the same reasons I am. Nice try at changing the subject, though.

    As a blogger, you broadcast your opinion publicly to be judged. People sitting at tables don't. It makes a good story, I guess. And sucker punching is so easy. But there's more to life, and I thought I'd add a little reality to this conversation. Judge not lest ye..., etc.

    You got the point, sort of, though you still haven't acclimated to NYC. We're all crammed together here, and sometimes public is private, because it has to be. You could spend your life waiting for space and privacy instead of just getting on with it. We have to let each other get on with it. The place for your rage is...your blog.

    And, it's "graceless."

    ReplyDelete
  8. Of course I like it when people agree with me! I think that's pretty normal. As for being "graceless" - I'm pretty sure I never claimed to have a whole hell of a lot of grace. And if I did, I apologize, because that is ridiculous. I have no grace. Not necessarily proud of it- but oh well. Sometimes you wake up in a shitty mood and the first thing you read is someone anonymously shitting on your blog, and you are an immature bitch about it. You, meaning me.

    The bottom line is this- I was empathetic to the burnt out mom, and I have a big mouth. You don't like my writing style, personality, whatever- and that is totally fine. So you can visit my blog and hate it. You can hate it so much that you actually feel compelled to post an anonymous comment. But I don't put my opinions out there to be "judged" as you say. I put them out there to connect with people who are like me, who would probably be my friends in real life. I put my opinions out there to feel less isolated as a struggling mom in Brooklyn.

    In summary... fuck off.

    ReplyDelete